FBoy Island Season 1 Cast List – Where Are the FBoy Contestants Now? – menshealth.com

Our product picks are editor-tested, expert-approved. We may earn a commission through links on our site.
The 30 singles are ready to mingle.
Spoiler Warning: The following contains details from FBOY Island Season 1.
If you’re a true reality TV fan, you’ve probably binge watched all of the 90 Day Fiance series, Love Is Blind, The Bachelor and Love Island you can stand. It’s time for something new. It’s time…for FBOY Island.
Set in the Cayman Islands, three women are tasked with finding love while not getting played. 24 men are on the island with them. 12 are self-identified “Nice Guys” looking for a relationship just like them. And 12 are “F-Boys,” who just want to play with their hearts. For some reason, the show never says the real curse word, because even though the show is on HBOMax, a show about a bunch of sexy singles trapped on an island is supposed to be family-friendly?
Regardless, there’s still more to the show than just dating. There’s also a cash prize of $100,000. Whoever manages to make it to the end of the show has a chance to win the money, both the men and women. Which means hearts will be broken, games will be played, and maybe, just maybe, a couple will emerge out of all of this.
If money and drama weren’t enough, there’s also a twist revealed in the first few episodes. All of the eliminated contestants don’t go home. Instead, they’re shipped off to “Limbro” and “Nice Guy Grotto” according to what they identified as when joining the show. As expected, Nice Guy Grotto is paradise. Limbro? Let’s just say it gives us Survivor vibes.
On top of all this, episode three revealed there’s more than just the original 27 cast members. Three new men joined the show to try and win the women’s hearts, and brought a whole new world of drama with them.
Naturally, you’re probably wondering: who would join such a wild show? Well, for anyone curious, we have the full cast—all 30 of them—below for your viewing pleasure, and spoilers on who ended up with who. Scroll down and enjoy.
Nakia is a hair and makeup stylist, and a singer-songwriter from Los Angeles. She says she’s been burned by F-Boys in the past, and thinks she can call out a player when she sees one.
In the finale, Nakia picked OG Jared to couple with. Jared agreed, and announced he was a reformed F-Boy. Aw.
A post shared by ℕ𝕒𝕜𝕚𝕒 ℝ𝕖𝕟𝕖𝕖 (@nakia.renee)
CJ is a model, comedian and actress from Los Angeles. Throughout the season, CJ had an on and off again romance with Casey, but their relationship was cut short in a double elimination. She turned her attention to New Jarred.
Even with Casey’s return later in the season, New Jarred proved to be a dependable, respectful Nice Guy. They coupled up in the finale.
A post shared by Cj Franco (@itscjfranco)
This social media manager from Chicago, Illinois is an adventurer. Per her Instagram, it looks like she loves to go boating, travel and all around have a good time.
During the competition, Sarah quickly gravitated toward Garrett Morosky and the two managed to make it to the end, despite Garrett having a secret relationship right before going on the show. In the finale, Sarah chose him, only for Garrett to turn around and admit he was only in it for the money.
Sarah was the true winner though. That money Garrett thought he’d win? It actually went to Sarah for a charity of her choosing.
A post shared by Sarah Emig | FBOY Island (@sarah.emig)
According to his Instagram, Ryan is an outdoorsman and an avid cat lover. Unfortunately, Ryan had a medical emergency and had to leave the show without making much of a mark on the ladies.
A post shared by Ryan Rhino Garland (@primordial_ohm)
Charley Santos is a model and fitness trainer from Los Angeles. He loves all sorts of exercise including MMA, parkour, and yoga. In the second episode, Charley caused drama when he was chosen to leave and said he was a Nice Guy. Producers whispered in host Nikki Glaser’s ear he was lying, and Charley got sent to Limbro with the rest of the F-Boys.
A post shared by @fitlikecharley
This real estate broker from New York City likes to travel, go to nightclubs, and play tennis. On the show, Chris hoped to win the cash and scam the women by feeding them information about the other players. In episode three, he was up for elimination, but got saved when Sarah let him stay in place of Matt. His time finally came in episode six though, when he was eliminated along with Jomar.
A post shared by Chris Gillis | FBOY Island (@imchrisgillis)
Collin is a barber and photographer from Toledo, Ohio. For fun, he likes to shop, hang with friends and, of course, take photos. Although he got close with Nakia, Collin’s rivalry with OG Jared proved to be his downfall. Nakia decided not to choose him as one of her top two.
A post shared by Collin Carter – FBOY Island (@collincarter8)
This Behavioral Health Technician from Charlotte, North Carolina is big on working out. He’s even got his own TikTok where he shows off his routines. Anthony left the island in the double elimination of episode four.
A post shared by ANTHONY REED | FBOY ISLAND (@trigga_live)
Casey is an IT engineer recruiter from Toledo, Ohio. He likes to read, golf and find new recipes to cook. While on the island, Casey quickly snatched CJ’s heart. But after his friend Garrett caused drama, CJ asked him to stay away and focus on her. Trying to “be a man,” he pushed back and landed himself in elimination.
Although CJ wanted him to stay, he got removed in a surprise double elimination, then went on a tirade about how CJ didn’t deserve love. He got sent off to Limbro, then surprisingly returned to the island and made it into CJ’s top two. In the finale, CJ decided to go with New Jarred instead of Casey.
A post shared by Casey Johnson | FBOY Island (@caseyis___)
This image consultant from Las Vegas is also a Cirque Du Soleil performer. Everyone, from Nice Guys to F-Boys loved Chaun. He made a late season connection with CJ after Casey was eliminated. But Casey’s returned spelled the end of their relationship.
A post shared by Chaun Williams | FBoy Island (@chaunwilliams)
Divij does a lot in his free time, including selling houses, and working on his melatonin company. In the second episode, Divij found himself in hot water when another contestant revealed he’d called CJ “high-maintenance” and said she never reads books. The certified F-Boy was promptly eliminated, and CJ wished him well on his journey to find a low-maintenance girl.
A post shared by FBOY Island – Divij (@divijvaswani)
Andrew is a firefighter and an EMT from Savannah, Georgia. He loves being active, whether it’s hiking, working out, or hanging with friends. Andrew got eliminated in the first episode, along with Garratt and Peter. Tough break.
A post shared by Andrew Dietz – FBOY Island (@_andrewdietz_)
A real-estate agent from Las Vegas, Cameron likes to read, work out, and talk to his mom whenever he can. Cameron was eliminated in episode four but got sent to Nice Guy Grotto to enjoy the rest of his time on the island.
The Los Angeles “cryptocurrency guru” is an animal lover and likes to travel. Garrett stole Sarah’s heart for most of the season, even though he revealed he had a relationship before joining the show and said some not nice things about Sarah behind her back.
In the final episode, Sarah asked Garrett to enter a relationship. Like the F-Boy he is, he revealed he was only in it for the money, and not for Sarah’s heart. He “won” the $100,000, which ended up actually going to a charity of Sarah’s choosing.
A post shared by FBOY Island – Garrett 🧸 (@garrett_morosky)
Jamie works at Ohio State Athletics, and per his Instagram, is a serious mental health advocate. In episode three, Jamie was eliminated and revealed to be a Nice Guy.
Jared is a jack of all trades. He writes poetry, plays chess, skates, hikes, and more. As of episode six, OG Jared is still in the competition. He revealed he was falling in love with Nakia, which prompted host Nikki to reveal everyone’s F-Boy/Nice Guy status.
Despite his controversial F-Boy past, Nakia chose OG Jared and he happily accepted.
A post shared by OGJared | HBO (@ogjared_)
This event producer from Honolulu has been to 49 countries. And traveling isn’t his only hobby. He also makes music, sails, dances, and more. Kevin was eliminated in episode 4 after not making much of a connection with the women.
A post shared by Kevin Sun | Fboy Island (@thesunexperience)
This Los Angeles chiropractor made it into Nakia’s top two against OG Jared in the final episode. Despite the late-game connections the two made, Nakia decided to with OG Jared instead. Ouch.
A post shared by Fernando Titus | FBOY Island (@_nandeezy)
Greg is a content creator from Los Angeles. He’s already got over 200,000 followers. Whether or not he’s a certified FBoy or Nice Guy, FBoy Island will definitely bring him some more. Although he got close with Nakia, Greg didn’t make it into her top two.
A post shared by Metelus | FBOY Island (@_metelus)
Per his social media, Israel loves traveling, hanging with friends, and working on his alternative health company. F-Boy Israel was eliminated in the second episode along with Divij and Charley.

A post shared by Israel Dimri | FBOY Island (@israel_dimri)
Josh is a brand marketer from Chicago and in his free time he hosts a podcast and makes music. Sparks flew between Sarah and Josh and he managed to make it into her top two. Unfortunately, Sarah chose Garrett as her number one guy instead of Josh. Still, he took the rejection well, like any Nice Guy would.
When he’s not out firefighting, Garratt writes poetry, makes 3D art, and is a screenwriter.
Poor Garratt got eliminated in the first episode since he came on a little too strong for Nakia. Before he left the main island, Garratt revealed he self-identified as a “Nice Guy.” Maybe Nice Guys really do finish last.
This New York City investment banker is a big fan of dad jokes. Besides that, he likes to run, lift weights, and read historical biographies. Mark was revealed to be a Nice Guy and got sent to Nice Guy Grotto in the third episode.
A post shared by Mark Moran (@itsmarkmoran)
Paul is a fridge mover? And also a surf and yoga instructor. Paul was eliminated in episode four during the double elimination.
A post shared by Paul Keating | FBoy Island (@hi_im___paul)
Peter is a model from Virginia who loves to travel, work out, and most importantly, take power naps. Sounds like he has his priorities straight.
In the first episode, Peter was revealed to be an F-Boy after he starting talking about kids and marriage right out of the gate. He was put in the show’s Limbro after elimination to think about every life choice that led him to becoming an F-Boy.
A post shared by Peter Park (@thekoreanpapi)
Matt is an Army National Guardsman and a home renovation salesman. Although he was revealed as a Nice Guy, Matt got booted in episode three and spilled a few secrets before he left, including that Garrett Morosky possibly had someone waiting for him at home.
A post shared by Matt Chamberlin| FBOY Island (@matthew_chamberlin_)
Tariq is a nutritionist and kickboxing instructor. In his free time, he likes to take long drives, travel, and play his guitar. Tariq was eliminated in episode four.
A post shared by Tariq Johnson | FBoy Island (@tariqjohnsxn)
Introduced in episode three, New Jarred ruffled a few feathers and swept Nakia off her feet. The actor, model, and professional football player looks like he loves to travel and take shirtless photos for his Instagram.
Once Casey left the main island, New Jarred grew close with CJ. The two had such great chemistry, CJ chose to start a relationship with New Jarred in the finale.
A post shared by Jarred Evans (@jarred_evans)
Another episode three addition, Jomar is an actor, model and general manager at an insurance agency. Unfortunately, Jomar was eliminated in episode six, lasting only three episodes on the main island.
The club promoter and pro-gamer from Miami loves, you guessed it, to play video games and hang out at the clubs. During the show, it’s revealed Welcome is an F-Boy who likes to play with hearts like video games.
Welcome was almost eliminated in episode five, but managed to stay. He made a connection with Sarah toward the end of the season, but didn’t end up in her top two.


Book an appointment